I love checking out indie lines. There was a time when I did almost all of my skin care product shopping through Etsy. I dabble in making skin care products and soap so it's natural for me to look for lines that use ingredients I'm comfortable and familiar with. If you're stuck in a drugstore or Sephora rut, I'd definitely recommend perusing the "isles" of Etsy for a while. You'll find something amazing.
Like Anatomy Naturals. This line uses the best ingredients for the skin and doesn't use the controversial ones that you might be trying to avoid. The line is quite large for a small company and has products for your entire body, head to toe.
Image provided by Anatomy Naturals